Please Please Me Review: Calam Lynch Shines as Brian Epstein in Kiln Theatre's Beatles Drama

The story of The Beatles has been told countless times, but the man who discovered them, shaped them, and ultimately lost himself in the process remains curiously underexplored on stage. Tom Wright's debut play Please Please Me, now running at the Kiln Theatre under Amit Sharma's direction, attempts to rectify that imbalance. The result is a production that, while uneven in execution, features a genuinely moving central performance and shines a light on one of pop culture's most tragically overlooked figures.

Brian Epstein: The Fifth Beatle Finally Gets His Spotlight

Brian Epstein was the Liverpool record shop manager who walked into the Cavern Club, saw four scruffy young musicians, and recognised something world-changing. He negotiated their first record deal, transformed their image, and steered them from local obscurity to global superstardom. Yet his own story is defined by shadows: he was Jewish and gay at a time when homosexuality was a criminal offence in Britain, and he died in 1967 at the age of just 32, alone and increasingly dependent on drugs.

Wright's play attempts to chart this entire arc, from Epstein's early encounters with the band through to his lonely demise. It is an ambitious undertaking, and the playwright deserves credit for the directness with which he tackles the more difficult aspects of Epstein's life. The opening scene sets the tone immediately: Epstein and his upright father are confronted by a man who blackmails them after a sexual encounter, a stark reminder that consensual sex between men was still punishable by imprisonment in 1960s Britain.

A Standout Performance from Calam Lynch

The strongest argument for seeing Please Please Me is Calam Lynch's deeply felt portrayal of Epstein. Lynch brings both charm and vulnerability to the role, capturing a man whose visionary instincts in the music industry were matched only by the private anguish he carried. As the play progresses, Lynch charts Epstein's gradual disintegration with painful precision, showing a figure slowly destroyed by the shame imposed upon him by a society that could not accept who he was.

What makes Lynch's performance particularly impressive is the way he communicates layers that the script itself does not always provide. There is more going on behind his eyes than in the dialogue he is given to speak, and he generates genuine warmth and sympathy even when the writing around him leans towards exposition. It is a performance that honours Epstein as both a visionary and a deeply unhappy man, and it anchors the production through its more unsteady passages.

Eleanor Worthington-Cox's Versatile Supporting Turn

Eleanor Worthington-Cox takes on multiple female roles, including Cilla Black (another of Epstein's management clients), John Lennon's formidable Aunt Mimi, and his wife Cynthia. Her portrayal of Cilla is particularly affectionate, presenting the singer as one of the few people in Epstein's orbit who both understood him and genuinely cared for his wellbeing. Despite being hampered by some unfortunate costume choices, Worthington-Cox brings real personality and texture to each of her characters.

William Robinson and Arthur Wilson offer strong support across a variety of roles, while Noah Ritter makes his stage debut as John Lennon. Lennon is notably the only Beatle to appear in the play, and the script presents a complicated dynamic between manager and artist, one that extends beyond the professional. The production draws on Yoko Ono's well-known assertion that Lennon told her he and Epstein had a sexual encounter during a holiday in Torremolinos. However, Ritter faces an uphill struggle: he neither looks nor sounds especially like Lennon, and the writing gives him little room to convey the danger and magnetism that made the real man so compelling. Too often, he is required simply to explain his own character rather than reveal it through action.

Fluid Direction and Evocative Design

Amit Sharma's staging handles the play's many location shifts with considerable fluidity. Tom Piper's set design proves cleverly adaptable, transforming from a furniture shop in 1961 Liverpool to a Spanish holiday resort to the iconic Cavern Club with relative ease. The Cavern sequence is especially atmospheric: Lennon emerges from an archway as a silhouetted figure, framed by Rory Beaton's warm spotlights, conjuring a sense of the excitement and mystique that surrounded those early performances.

Yet there is a significant limitation that the production cannot overcome. Rights issues mean that no Beatles music features in the show. For a play about the man who brought The Beatles to the world, this absence is deeply felt. Without the music, the production must rely entirely on dialogue and staging to convey the extraordinary cultural impact of Epstein's achievement, and the script does not always rise to that challenge.

Where the Script Struggles

The fundamental difficulty with Please Please Me is one of scope. Wright's play has to cover an enormous amount of ground, tracing Epstein from his pre-Beatles life through to the band's meteoric rise and his own decline and death. The consequence is that the narrative becomes a series of incidents rather than a sustained dramatic journey. Scenes shift rapidly from place to place, and large portions of the dialogue are given over to exposition, with characters explaining to one another (and to the audience) what is happening and how they feel about it.

This structural approach means there is little space for genuine exploration of Epstein's increasingly fractured psychological state. We are told he is suffering, and Lynch's performance makes us believe it, but the writing does not delve deeply enough into the specifics of his unravelling. Characters occasionally resort to platitudes when the drama calls for something sharper and more particular. As a debut play, it shows real ambition and genuine emotional commitment, but it also reveals the challenges of condensing such a rich and complex life into a single theatrical sitting.

Historical Context: Why Epstein's Story Matters Now

One of the play's most valuable contributions is the way it frames the 1960s as a period that, despite its reputation for cultural liberation, remained profoundly hostile to gay men. The era of Beatlemania was closer in time to the Second World War than to our own digital age, and the legal and social persecution of homosexuality was very much a living reality. Epstein managed the most famous band on the planet while hiding a fundamental part of his identity, and the toll this took on him was immense.

In an era when LGBTQ+ stories are increasingly, and rightly, being told across all art forms, Epstein's particular tragedy resonates powerfully. He was a man whose creative brilliance and personal courage transformed popular culture, yet who was denied the right to live openly and honestly. Please Please Me may not tell his story with complete dramatic assurance, but it tells it with compassion and conviction, and Lynch's performance ensures that the emotional truth of Epstein's life is powerfully communicated.

Should You Book?

Please Please Me runs at the Kiln Theatre until 29 May 2025. For theatregoers with an interest in Beatles history, LGBTQ+ narratives, or simply fine acting, Calam Lynch's central performance alone makes this worth the trip to Kilburn. The play has its shortcomings, particularly in its episodic structure and the absence of Beatles music, but it tackles important and often overlooked material with heart and sincerity. If you go in expecting a character study rather than a comprehensive biographical epic, you are likely to find much to admire.

Looking for more new plays on London's stages? Browse our full list of current shows or explore our selection of plays running across the capital's theatres.